Read the post as text
No one’s hands are clean here. However, Mr. Secretary Buttigieg, you had four years in the job and infrastructure money, yet made zero progress modernizing the FAA. You left a failing system in place. THANKS!
A viral post blames Buttigieg for an aging air traffic system. The age is real. "Zero progress" isn't. Friday's outage has no official cause yet.

No one’s hands are clean here. However, Mr. Secretary Buttigieg, you had four years in the job and infrastructure money, yet made zero progress modernizing the FAA. You left a failing system in place. THANKS!
Under Buttigieg, the FAA awarded a contract to replace its decades-old telecom network and began a five-year, $5 billion facilities program1,2. "Zero progress" is wrong. But the FAA's 2023 operational risk assessment rated 51 of its 138 air traffic systems unsustainable3. No official cause for Friday's outage has been announced4.
What the post says or clearly implies, checked one by one. How verdicts work
Progress was slow, but it wasn't zero. His FAA awarded the contract to replace its 2002-era telecom network and began a five-year, $5 billion program for air traffic facilities. It also hit its controller hiring goals, a staffing measure.
The 2021 infrastructure law gave the FAA $25 billion over five years. Only $5 billion of it, $1 billion a year, went to air traffic control facilities and equipment5,2. The rest mostly went to airport grants and terminals6,7. The first $1 billion was earmarked for power systems, radar sites, en route centers and tower design8.
In March 2023 the FAA picked Verizon to replace the telecom backbone that L3Harris has run since 2002, aiming to retire its older copper-based technology by 20271. Hiring is staffing, not modernization, but the FAA met its 2023 goal of 1,500 controllers and beat its fiscal 2024 goal with 1,811 hires, the most in nearly a decade, it said9,10.
Duffy's own boast is about pace. He says his FAA replaced more copper wire with fiber in one year "than Joe Biden & Pete Buttigieg did in all FOUR YEARS"11. GAO also faulted the pace, saying in 2024 that the FAA had been "slow to modernize" its most critical systems3.
The FAA's 2023 risk assessment rated much of the system unsustainable on his watch. But it had aged for decades amid inconsistent funding, and the FAA's own $5.3 billion backlog estimate exceeded the law's five-year $5 billion.
The FAA's 2023 operational risk assessment rated 51 of its 138 air traffic systems unsustainable and 54 more potentially unsustainable, GAO reported in September 20243. An independent safety review the FAA commissioned that year warned that a "confluence" of challenges, including staffing and aging equipment, was "rendering the current level of safety unsustainable"12.
That review said "Federal budget processes and constraints have led to inadequate, inconsistent reinvestment in legacy systems." It counted 21 en route centers in buildings 56 to 64 years old12 (the FAA's infrastructure page says 22 centers2). It cited an FAA estimate of a $5.3 billion backlog of facility components past their service lives, across more than 12,500 equipment sites and 500 staffed facilities12. That 2023 tally of overdue work exceeds the law's $5 billion for facilities and equipment over 2022–20262.
Nearly two years into the Trump administration, the 2002-era network is still in service. In August 2026 the FAA moved its replacement from Verizon to AT&T, saying the old network can no longer support air traffic operations13.
No official cause has been announced. CBS News's sources point to an update to the network, and Duffy has blamed old routers and copper lines. Emanuel posted before Duffy's briefing.
The FAA halted departures nationwide Friday for about five hours, citing a "telecommunication outage." FlightAware listed more than 10,000 delays and over 4,000 cancellations4. Emanuel never mentions the outage, but posted during it, at 6:37 p.m. Eastern by X's timestamp. Deadline reported it as blaming Buttigieg14. That was before the FAA reopened the airspace at 8:15 and before Duffy's briefing4.
Duffy's accounts have varied. Deadline reported him calling the root cause a radar "instability" issue14. CBS quoted him on routers "overloaded with data"4, and he blamed "1980s little copper lines"15. Sources told CBS News that an update to the L3Harris-run network caused it to reboot, and Homeland Security Secretary Markwayne Mullin said new security patches appeared to "overwhelm" the older system's routers4. Duffy said, "I didn't anticipate that we would have an outage like this"16.
The previous nationwide stop, in January 2023, lasted a few hours4. A preliminary FAA review traced it to contract staff who unintentionally deleted files in a flight-safety notice system17.
Facts can't settle this part, so we don't rule on it.
When an old, shared system fails, how much blame belongs to the last person in charge, and how much to decades of funding decisions by Congresses and administrations?
Emanuel opened with "No one's hands are clean here." He is executive chairman of WME and CEO of TKO16,15. Trump considers him a close friend, Deadline reports14, and his brother Rahm is a possible 2028 presidential candidate18. That night Duffy blamed old equipment and past administrations, while Buttigieg pushed back and demanded answers15.
Buttigieg had the warnings, the money and four years. The system he handed over is his record.
Buttigieg's own FAA was warned. Its 2023 safety review called the level of safety unsustainable12, and GAO found the agency "slow to modernize" its most critical systems3. The telecom contract awarded in 2023 hadn't replaced the old network when he left13, and GAO's call for a cost and schedule baseline was still open in 20253. His FAA also moved Newark's approach control to Philadelphia in July 2024. The inspector general opened an audit of the move after outages19, and Duffy has pushed for that inquiry20.
Duffy says past administrations got $15 billion over 25 years to fix air traffic control and "barely anything was done"15. Once Congress approved $12.5 billion in 2025, his department says it replaced nearly half of all copper wires and installed 40 voice switches11. The FAA hired 2,026 controllers in fiscal 202521.
The system decayed over several administrations and Congresses. Buttigieg started the fixes, and blaming him won't speed them up.
The FAA's 2023 review blamed "Federal budget processes and constraints"12. The infrastructure law gave air traffic facilities $1 billion a year2, less than the $5.3 billion of overdue facility components the FAA tallied in 202312. His FAA awarded the contract to replace the 2002 telecom network1. When he asked Congress for money to hire thousands more controllers, House Republicans blocked it, NPR reported22. The American Economic Liberties Project, an advocacy group, credits him with "meaningful steps"23.
The Trump administration laid off hundreds of FAA employees in 2025, though officials said not controllers22. It has had nearly two years in office and, since 2025, $12.5 billion24. CBS News's sources say Friday's failure followed an update to the network, which L3Harris runs4. "When we had an outage, I didn't stand there complaining about the Trump administration," Buttigieg said. "We got to work"15.
Every source was opened and read. Advocacy groups are labeled as such.
Think we got something wrong? Email editor@viewfromthegallery.com with a source. Corrections are made openly and logged on the page.
New breakdowns in your inbox: what was true, what wasn't, and what the argument is really about. No ads, no spin.