Then and now · Education · Schools

Closing schools for lack of kids isn't new. The 1970s drop was bigger.

Enrollment fell harder after 1971, and births fell harder after 1961. Today's closure spike is measured from a pandemic low.

Is it new?

Is today's spike in school closures, driven by shrinking enrollment, something new?

“School closures have spiked 35% across the country over the past four years, propelled by a shrinking youth population and the end of COVID-19 relief funds that had propped up education funding in some places.”1

Todd Wallack, Washington Post reporter, in a story the Philadelphia Inquirer ran under the headline "Shrinking student populations cause spike in public school closures across U.S.", Jul 20, 2026

Our answer: We've been here before

The bottom line

We've been here before. U.S. public enrollment fell 15% from 1971 to 1984, against 2.8% so far since 2019, and births fell harder then too. Today's closure spike is measured from a pandemic low, and Brookings puts the 2023–24 closure rate below 2014–15's. Pittsburgh has been shrinking for over 45 years.

Then ·

“Parents, who as taxpayers may favor cost-efficiency moves, suddenly find it outrageous that their children's school has been targeted for closing.”2

The Christian Science Monitor: Parents cry: 'Don't close our school'

Now ·

“School administrators acknowledge that the moves can be hard on students, families, and neighborhoods.”1

The Washington Post, in The Philadelphia Inquirer: Shrinking student populations cause spike in public school closures across U.S.

Then ·

“Since the early 1970's, enrollment in the system has dropped from over 75,000 to approximately 45,000.”3

Education Week: Pittsburgh Votes New Priorities, Long Term Plan

Now ·

“The district lost about a quarter of its student population across the 2013-14 and 2023-24 school years, according to Pittsburgh Public Schools.”4

K-12 Dive: Pittsburgh Public Schools OKs plan to close 12 schools

What happened

U.S. births fell from 4,268,326 in 1961 to 3,136,965 in 19735. Public school enrollment peaked at 46.1 million in fall 1971 and fell every year to 39.2 million in fall 19846. NCES ties the decline in total enrollment, public and private, to a shrinking school-age population7. By 1980 the Monitor was reporting closings around the country, justified by the fuel and upkeep costs of emptying buildings2. NCES counted 89,372 public schools with reported grade spans in 1970–71 and 81,147 in 1984–85, a span that crosses its 1982–83 switch to a new survey8.

Then the children came back. Births topped 4 million again in 1989, and enrollment climbed to 50.8 million in fall 20195,9.

Pittsburgh never got that rebound. The district went from over 75,000 students in the early 1970s to about 45,000 in 1981, when the board approved closing 18 schools over 10 years3. It held near 40,000 from 1987 to 1997, while national enrollment grew 15% by our calculation10,6,9. A 2000 plan to close 12 schools was its first multi-school closing since 1980, and Education Week already listed charter schools beside lower birthrates as reasons city districts were shrinking11. Rounds followed in 2004, 2006 and 201212,13,14.

The Post's 35% compares more than 1,000 closings in 2025–26 with 755 in 2021–22, when, the same story says, closures had slowed while districts spent pandemic relief funds1. We couldn't check those counts in NCES's files. The longer record points the other way: Brookings puts the closure rate at 0.8% in 2023–24, below 1.3% in 2014–1515. In May 2026 Pittsburgh's board approved a plan that K-12 Dive says closes 12 schools and TribLive says shutters nine buildings4,16.

Births fell 27% from 1961 to 1973, and 16% from 2007 to 2025

births

1961–732007–2501M2M3M4M5M1940195019601970198019902000201020201961: 4.27 million1973: 3.14 million2007: 4.32 million2025: 3.61 million
Live births in the United States. 1940–1958 are NCHS estimates adjusted for under-registration, rounded to thousands. Registered births from 1959. Where sources overlap (2010–2018, 2024) the counts match. Percent changes are our calculation. Source: CDC/NCHS.
Show the numbers
Births, 1940–20185NCHS dataset. 1940–1958 adjusted for under-registration and rounded to thousands
Whenbirths
19402,559,000
19412,703,000
19422,989,000
19433,104,000
19442,939,000
19452,858,000
19463,411,000
19473,817,000
19483,637,000
19493,649,000
19503,632,000
19513,820,000
19523,909,000
19533,959,000
19544,071,000
19554,097,000
19564,210,000
19574,300,000
19584,246,000
19594,244,796
19604,257,850
19614,268,326
19624,167,362
19634,098,020
19644,027,490
19653,760,358
19663,606,274
19673,520,959
19683,501,564
19693,600,206
19703,731,386
19713,555,970
19723,258,411
19733,136,965
19743,159,958
19753,144,198
19763,167,788
19773,326,632
19783,333,279
19793,494,398
19803,612,258
19813,629,238
19823,680,537
19833,638,933
19843,669,141
19853,760,561
19863,756,547
19873,809,394
19883,909,510
19894,040,958
19904,158,212
19914,110,907
19924,065,014
19934,000,240
19943,952,767
19953,899,589
19963,891,494
19973,880,894
19983,941,553
19993,959,417
20004,058,814
20014,025,933
20024,021,726
20034,089,950
20044,112,052
20054,138,349
20064,265,555
20074,316,233
20084,247,694
20094,130,665
20103,999,386
20113,953,590
20123,952,841
20133,932,181
20143,988,076
20153,978,497
20163,945,875
20173,855,500
20183,791,712
Births, final 2010–202417Table 1, final data
Whenbirths
20103,999,386
20113,953,590
20123,952,841
20133,932,181
20143,988,076
20153,978,497
20163,945,875
20173,855,500
20183,791,712
20193,747,540
20203,613,647
20213,664,292
20223,667,758
20233,596,017
20243,628,934
Births, final 2024–202518Final 2025 data
Whenbirths
20243,628,934
20253,612,012

Public enrollment fell 15% after 1971, then rose to a 2019 high

thousand students

1971–84Since 2019020,00040,00060,0001950196019701980199020002010202020301971 peak: 46.1 million1984 low: 39.2 million2019 peak: 50.8 million
Public elementary and secondary enrollment, 50 states and D.C., pre-K included. NCES says pre-K was undercounted before 1992, so part of the rise to 2019 is fuller counting. 1949 is a school-year count, later years fall counts. Dashed line: NCES's 2023 projection. Percent change is our calculation. Source: NCES Digest.
Show the numbers
Enrollment, 1949–19896Public total, in thousands. This table also gives 1990–1995. Those values match the 2025 edition exactly, so they are drawn from it.
Whenthousand students
194925,111
195935,182
196441,416
196542,173
196643,039
196743,891
196844,944
196945,550
197045,894
197146,071
197245,726
197345,445
197445,073
197544,819
197644,311
197743,577
197842,551
197941,651
198040,877
198140,044
198239,566
198339,252
198439,208
198539,422
198639,753
198740,008
198840,189
198940,543
Enrollment, 1980–20249All grades, in thousands. The table skips 1981–84 and 1986–89.
Whenthousand students
198040,877
198539,422
199041,217
199142,047
199242,823
199343,465
199444,111
199544,840
199645,611
199746,127
199846,539
199946,857
200047,204
200147,672
200248,183
200348,540
200448,795
200549,113
200649,316
200749,291
200849,266
200949,361
201049,484
201149,522
201249,771
201350,045
201450,313
201550,438
201650,615
201750,686
201850,694
201950,796
202049,375
202149,433
202249,618
202349,516
202449,387
NCES projection19Projected, from Projections of Education Statistics to 2031. Actual fall 2023 and 2024 came in at 49,516 and 49,387.
Whenthousand students
202349,012
202448,707
202548,228
202647,644
202747,370
202847,184
202947,028
203046,940
203146,890

Same then as now, and what's different

Same then as now

  • Fewer children lead the explanation both times, and births fell harder from 1961 to 1973 (26.5%) than from 2007 to 2025 (16.3%), by our calculation from NCHS2,1,5,18.
  • Closings were sold as savings both times: the Monitor called the motive "largely financial," and Pittsburgh expects its plan to save about $4 million in 2027 and $8 million in 20282,4.
  • Midwest and Northeast declines recur: the Monitor reported the steepest losses there in 1980, and from 2000 to 2024 Northeast enrollment fell 7.7% and Midwest 5.7%, by our calculation from NCES2,20.

What's different

  • The national drop is smaller so far: 14.9% over the finished 1971–84 decline, 3.8% in its first five years, and 2.8% from 2019 to 2024, all of it in the 2020 step from 50.8 to 49.4 million, by our calculation from NCES6,9,20.
  • The count of public schools with reported grade spans rose through 2022–23, from 97,868 in 2019–20 to 98,768, after falling through the 1970s and early 1980s8.
  • Federal pandemic relief changed the timing: closures slowed while the money lasted, and the Post ties the current rise to its end. Marguerite Roza of Georgetown says some families, as in Florida, are using taxpayer-funded vouchers and scholarships1.

Pittsburgh's enrollment never came back

students

020,00040,00060,00080,000197519801985199019952000200520102015202020251981: plan to close 182000: plan to close 122006: 22 schools to close2026: 12 schools to close
Pittsburgh Public Schools enrollment. Dots for 1971 and 1981 are Education Week's rounded, reported figures. 1979 and 1980 from court records, 1987–2004 from NCES's Common Core of Data via the Urban Institute, 2004–2025 from Pennsylvania's October counts, which include pre-K. No yearly counts found before 1979 or for 1981–86.
Show the numbers
Reported, rounded3Rounded figures as reported in 1981: "over 75,000" in the early 1970s, plotted at 1971, and "approximately 45,000" in 1981. Education Week in 2001 quoted the superintendent putting it at 80,000 about 30 years earlier.
Whenstudents
197175,000
198145,000
Court finding, 1979–8021School population in 1979–80, as found by the Commonwealth Court. The same finding projected 46,228 for September 1980.
Whenstudents
197948,795
Court finding, fall 198022"Present approximate school population," opinion of Sept. 18, 1980
Whenstudents
198046,945
NCES CCD, 1987–200410Fall of each school year. 1986 has no enrollment value in the file.
Whenstudents
198739,921
198839,809
198939,559
199039,896
199140,384
199240,445
199340,107
199439,716
199539,761
199639,955
199740,181
199839,602
199938,846
200038,560
200137,612
200235,146
200334,658
200434,131
Pennsylvania, 2004–202523October 1 counts for the school year starting that fall, pre-K included. 2025–26 includes 984 pre-K students. The district's own 2025–26 count, per K-12 Dive, is 17,937.
Whenstudents
200434,131
200532,506
200630,885
200727,680
200828,104
200927,945
201027,982
201126,653
201226,292
201326,041
201424,657
201524,190
201622,384
201722,370
201822,934
201922,665
202021,407
202120,112
202220,039
202319,774
202419,581
202519,122

What we couldn't confirm

  • Pittsburgh's peak enrollment. Education Week put it at over 75,000 in the early 1970s (1981) and at 80,000 about 30 years before 2001 (quoting the superintendent). We found no district count before 1979, or for 1981–86.
  • The Post's closure counts (755 in 2021–22, more than 1,000 in 2025–26) and its 35%. We didn't find the NCES release it cites.
  • Pittsburgh's closure counts differ by source: 22 schools in 2006 (Education Week) against 18 buildings (PublicSource), and 12 schools in 2026 (K-12 Dive) against nine buildings (TribLive).
  • National closings per year in the 1970s. We found only net counts of schools, and couldn't match the Monitor's 3 million fewer students or 3,456 fewer buildings to NCES tables. NCES shows 5.0 million fewer from fall 1970 to fall 1980.

Sources

Every source was opened and read. Advocacy groups are labeled as such.

Show all 23 sources
  1. 1
    Shrinking student populations cause spike in public school closures across U.S.
    The Philadelphia Inquirer (Washington Post story by Todd Wallack)2026-07-20Journalism
  2. 2
    Parents cry: 'Don't close our school'
    The Christian Science Monitor (Lucia Mouat)1980-03-14Journalism
  3. 3
    Pittsburgh Votes New Priorities, Long Term Plan
    Education Week1981-10-05Journalism
  4. 4
  5. 5
    NCHS - Births and General Fertility Rates: United States
    CDC, National Center for Health StatisticsData
  6. 6
  7. 7
  8. 8
  9. 9
  10. 10
    Education Data Portal: school district directory (NCES Common Core of Data), Pittsburgh SD, 1986–2004
    Urban InstituteDataNonpartisan research group; republishes federal NCES data
  11. 11
    Low Enrollment Prompts Cities To Shut Schools
    Education Week2001-05-09Journalism
  12. 12
    Past PPS closures haunt Pittsburgh's West Side families
    PublicSource2024-10-07JournalismNonprofit Pittsburgh newsroom
  13. 13
    City Districts Tackle Round of School Closings
    Education Week2006-03-15Journalism
  14. 14
    As PPS enrollment drops, some predict school closures
    PublicSource2023-01-19JournalismNonprofit Pittsburgh newsroom
  15. 15
    Exclusive Data Highlights Paradox: As Enrollment Falls, Fewer Schools Close
    The 74 (Linda Jacobson), reporting a Brookings Institution analysis2025-05-12JournalismNonprofit education news site
  16. 16
  17. 17
    Births: Final Data for 2024 (National Vital Statistics Reports, Vol. 75, No. 2)
    CDC, National Center for Health Statistics2026-06-09Data
  18. 18
    Births in the United States, 2025 (NCHS Data Brief No. 571)
    CDC, National Center for Health Statistics2026-10-21Data
  19. 19
  20. 20
  21. 21
    Pennsylvania Human Relations Commission v. Board of Education, 66 Pa. Commw. 219
    Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania (text via HallApproved.com)1982-04-20Primary document
  22. 22
    National Ass'n for Neighborhood Schools of Pittsburgh, Inc. v. Board of Public Education, 497 F. Supp. 471
    U.S. District Court, W.D. Pennsylvania (text via HallApproved.com)1980-09-18Primary document
  23. 23
    Public school enrollment reports, 2004–05 through 2025–26
    Pennsylvania Department of Education2026Data

Think we got something wrong? Email editor@viewfromthegallery.com with a source. Corrections are made openly and logged on the page.