One model projects a 5.0% raise by 2034 for legal workers with a high school diploma or less, if removals continue, and losses for others. Past enforcement programs lifted low-wage pay in places but cut US-born employment in better-paid jobs.
Penn Wharton modeled removing all "unauthorized" immigrants, including DACA and TPS holders, over 10 years. Legal workers with a high school diploma or less gain 5.0% by 2034 and 4.7% by 2054, "only if the deportation policy is permanently sustained." Workers with some college lose 1.5% by 2034 and 2.8% by 2054, and the average wage falls 0.4%, then 1.7%1. George Borjas found the 1980 Mariel boatlift cut Miami dropouts' pay 10% to 30%, a disputed finding2.
Actual enforcement programs raised low-wage pay in some places but cut US-born employment in better-paid jobs3,4. Where 2025's ICE surges hit, a working paper finds 1.3% fewer US-born men without college working, and no higher wages5,6.
Since outflows began, real hourly pay fell about 0.5% in the year to September amid an energy spike, and teen unemployment averaged 14.4% over the past year, versus 12.7% in 2024, by our calculation7,8,9. The Center for Immigration Studies counts 1.4 million more native-born workers from January 2025 to June 2026, but warns its survey links native and immigrant counts "mechanically"10.