Elections

Maricopa's overvote numbers can't explain Hobbs's 340,000-vote win

The adjudication figures come from a cropped, unverified screenshot, and the post misreads its dates. The handling the worker describes follows Arizona's rules.

Update,

Final unofficial counts moved the statewide margin to 340,129 (Hobbs 1,433,772, Biggs 1,093,643, as of Nov. 11)15 from 334,597 on Nov. 728. Maricopa's governor overvotes rose to 5,37316 from 5,31029. The county says its Board will canvass Nov. 188. Through Nov. 12 we found no county, state or court response to the adjudicator's allegations. Our verdicts are unchanged.

· @TheSCIF · on XThe post we're checking
ARIZONA election worker comes forward with allegations of ELECTION FRAUD exposing that 153,404 ballots were sent to adjudication with 54.7% flagged as overvotes, which is an extremely high number.

An inside Maricopa County ballot adjudicator claims she witnessed GOP votes for Andy Biggs systematically tossed as "overvotes," which gave the 2026 Arizona governor's race to Katie Hobbs.

The number of ballots flagged and adjudicated from Nov. 1-6 is extremely alarming.

- 153,404 ballots sent to adjudication.
- 54.70% flagged as overvotes.
- 27.82% ambiguous, 17.27% write-in.

Journalist Rachel Alexander, a former Maricopa elections attorney, was contacted by the election worker about the ongoing anomalies.

The Arizona ballot adjudicator claims she witnessed
Republican ballots marked for Biggs & Hobbs, with an X through the Biggs oval, which were then treated as overvotes.

Adjudicators then strip the Biggs vote, reading the X as  not what the voter intended to mark as their selection, which then awarded it to Hobbs.

Dual marks for Biggs plus Lombardo create overvotes where neither vote counts, cancelling them both out. This same pattern was appearing on Prop 144 and other races.

The election worker also noted that the ballots weren't stored in a secure location and were just in a hallway out in the open.

Maricopa County officials have not yet commented as these are new allegations being looked into, and 100% should be looked into, immediately.

The amount of flagged overvotes and adjudicated ballots in this race should tell you everything you need to know.

[Attached graphic: a photo of Katie Hobbs beside a red panel reading "153,404 Ballots Sent to Adjudication" and "54.7% of Ballots Flagged as Overvotes" above the Maricopa County seal, with The SCIF's logo.
Screenshot of the post on X. The graphic is The SCIF's. The post does not credit the photo of Katie Hobbs. Shown for commentary.
Read the post as text
ARIZONA election worker comes forward with allegations of ELECTION FRAUD exposing that 153,404 ballots were sent to adjudication with 54.7% flagged as overvotes, which is an extremely high number. An inside Maricopa County ballot adjudicator claims she witnessed GOP votes for Andy Biggs systematically tossed as "overvotes," which gave the 2026 Arizona governor's race to Katie Hobbs. The number of ballots flagged and adjudicated from Nov. 1-6 is extremely alarming. - 153,404 ballots sent to adjudication. - 54.70% flagged as overvotes. - 27.82% ambiguous, 17.27% write-in. Journalist Rachel Alexander, a former Maricopa elections attorney, was contacted by the election worker about the ongoing anomalies. The Arizona ballot adjudicator claims she witnessed Republican ballots marked for Biggs & Hobbs, with an X through the Biggs oval, which were then treated as overvotes. Adjudicators then strip the Biggs vote, reading the X as not what the voter intended to mark as their selection, which then awarded it to Hobbs. Dual marks for Biggs plus Lombardo create overvotes where neither vote counts, cancelling them both out. This same pattern was appearing on Prop 144 and other races. The election worker also noted that the ballots weren't stored in a secure location and were just in a hallway out in the open. Maricopa County officials have not yet commented as these are new allegations being looked into, and 100% should be looked into, immediately. The amount of flagged overvotes and adjudicated ballots in this race should tell you everything you need to know. [Attached graphic: a photo of Katie Hobbs beside a red panel reading "153,404 Ballots Sent to Adjudication" and "54.7% of Ballots Flagged as Overvotes" above the Maricopa County seal, with The SCIF's logo.]
Posted Nov 8, 2026About 350,000 views and 27,000 likes on X as of Nov. 9. The account has about 349,000 followers. The journalist's original posts drew about 179,000 and 99,000 views.See the original

The bottom line

The 153,404 and 54.7% figures come from a cropped screenshot nobody has verified, and its visible Nov. 1–6 rows total 56,477. Overvotes can be in any of about 80 contests. What the adjudicator describes matches Arizona's rules. Hobbs leads by 340,129, more than flipping every ballot in the screenshot would move.

The claims

What the post says or clearly implies, checked one by one. How verdicts work

1

153,404 ballots went to adjudication Nov. 1–6, 54.7% of them overvotes, an extremely high number.

Misleading

Even if the image is real, its own Nov. 1–6 rows total 56,477, not 153,404. And 153,404 would be about 9.8% of ballots, below 2020's 11.3%. No one has verified it.

The numbers trace to one image an unnamed adjudicator showed journalist Rachel Alexander1. It is cropped at the top and bottom. Its visible rows, Nov. 1 through Nov. 6, add up to 56,477 by our calculation, so the 153,404 must cover more than those six days, likely rows cut off above Nov. 1. Sites repeating the claim say it hasn't been independently verified2,3.

Any contest a scanner can't read sends a ballot to a bipartisan team4. Maricopa ballots averaged "over 80 contests" in 20245. In 2020 the county adjudicated 235,392 ballots, 11.3%6. Only 11,954 involved the presidential race, an unofficial bipartisan review of the county's cast-vote record found7.

If real, 153,404 is about 9.8% of the 1,559,706 voters in the county's final results, by our calculation8. As a baseline for the 54.7%: in 2020, 103,191 adjudicated ballots, 43.8% of those reviewed by our calculation (4.9% of all ballots), needed no change and counted as an overvote, blank or stray mark. Those categories overlap6. We found no county totals for 2022 or 2024.

2

Adjudicators systematically tossed Biggs votes as overvotes.

Misleading

Both cases follow Arizona's rules for every candidate: a clear change of mind counts, and two marks with no clear intent count for no one. Outsiders can't check individual calls, and nothing shown points to a pattern against Biggs.

The adjudicator described two kinds of ballots9. On one, the voter marked both Biggs and Hobbs, with an X through the Biggs mark. On the other, the voter filled in Biggs and the Green Party's Risa Lombardo10. The state manual lets a two-judge board11 resolve an overvote "if the voter's intent is clear." If it "cannot be positively determined, no selection shall be counted"12,13.

An X can also be a voter's way of marking a choice, so whether a crossed-out Biggs was a change of mind is the call the two judges make12. They are "equally divided between the two largest political parties," and every action is logged11. Party appointees and cameras watch4. A ballot doesn't record the voter's party, so "Republican ballots" is the adjudicator's inference from the marks.

We couldn't check the claim that ballots sat in an unsecured hallway. County updates say ballots ready for tabulation "are stored in a secure vault, under livestream cameras"14. Through Nov. 12 we found no county response to the allegation.

3

Biggs votes tossed as overvotes gave the 2026 Arizona governor's race to Katie Hobbs.

Wrong

Hobbs leads by 340,129 votes statewide, and Maricopa's governor race has 5,373 overvotes. Even if every adjudicated ballot in the screenshot had been a Biggs vote moved to Hobbs, she would still lead.

The state's unofficial results, as of Nov. 11, show Hobbs at 1,433,772 votes (55.63%) and Biggs at 1,093,643 (42.43%)15. In Maricopa's final file (Nov. 11), the governor's race has 5,373 overvotes, 0.35% of 1,555,545 governor ballots. That's the most of the 270 contests and the highest rate of any countywide race, about nine times the Secretary of State race (591). Prop 144's rate was 0.03%, by our calculation16. The file doesn't show whose. Even all 5,373 are 1.6% of the margin.

A ballot where a crossed-out Biggs became a Hobbs vote isn't an overvote in the final count. Test the screenshot's own total. If all 153,404 had been Biggs votes wrongly counted for Hobbs, reversing them would shift the margin by 306,808, still short of 340,129, by our calculation.

The AP called the race at 1:25 a.m. the morning after the election, with Hobbs near 57%17. That night Biggs acknowledged his campaign hadn't turned out voters as fully as it wanted10. Counties must canvass by Nov. 19, and the state by Nov. 2318.

The real disagreement

Facts can't settle this part, so we don't rule on it.

How much human judgment should go into counting ballots, and how much should election offices show the public when a worker says something is wrong?

Arizona lets bipartisan boards decide what a voter meant when a scanner can't11. Their decisions are logged, but the state Court of Appeals ruled in 2023 that Maricopa couldn't hand ballot images to the public19. After every election with a statewide race, boards chosen by the parties hand count a sample of ballots20,4.

Show the public the work

When a worker raises an alarm, outsiders should be able to check the ballots, and fewer ballots should need human calls.

When an adjudicator alleges voided Biggs votes, only the observers in the room can check, because Arizona keeps ballot images closed. In 2023 the Court of Appeals held that Maricopa "was not authorized under Arizona law to provide copies of the digital images of cast ballots"19. Then-House Speaker Ben Toma's bill to publish them, backed by Democratic Secretary of State Adrian Fontes, passed the Legislature and was vetoed21,22.

And an X isn't always a cancellation. The state manual sends ballots marked consistently with X's to these boards, to be counted if intent can be determined12. Only the image shows which it was. In 2022, 6.7% of Maricopa's Election Day ballots went into "Door 3", against 0.6% in that year's primary, after printers struggled with a 20-inch ballot23. In October, 54% of Republicans and 72% of Democrats were confident votes nationwide would be counted accurately24.

Let bipartisan boards read intent

Human review is how a changed mind gets counted, and the checks on it already exist.

A scanner can't tell a voter who crossed out Biggs and filled in Hobbs from one who wanted both. People can. Arizona gives that job to two judges from different parties11. When intent isn't clear, only that contest is lost, and "all other votes will count"4. Party-chosen boards hand count a sample afterward20.

Publishing every image has a cost. In small batches, a ballot can point back to its voter. At the 2023 hearing, a Democratic lawmaker warned that a lone braille ballot would reveal how that voter voted21. Full hand counts wouldn't be cleaner, with error rates up to 2 percent in a Rice and Clemson study25. The Senate's 2021 hand count of nearly 2.1 million Maricopa ballots moved Biden up 99 votes and Trump down 26126. Counters are under strain: 32 percent of local officials reported threats, harassment or abuse27.

Where they agree

  • Arizona already requires every adjudication call to be logged, and both sides want that kept11.
  • Neither side wants a voter who crossed out one choice and filled in another to lose that vote.

What would change minds

  • Maricopa's canvass breakdown of adjudicated overvotes and write-ins by contest, compared with 2020.
  • A sample of the crossed-out Biggs ballots, reviewed by observers from both parties against the adjudication log.
  • The county's hand-count audit results for the governor's race, if it was drawn20.

Sources

Every source was opened and read. Advocacy groups are labeled as such.

Show all 29 sources
  1. 1
    Post with the adjudication breakdown image
    Rachel Alexander (@Rach_IC) on X2026-11-07Primary documentThe image is cropped at the top and bottom. Rows before Nov. 1 are not visible. About 99,000 views as of Nov. 9.
  2. 2
  3. 3
  4. 4
    Just the Facts
    Maricopa County Elections DepartmentPrimary documentThe site blocks automated requests. We read it in a browser.
  5. 5
  6. 6
    Electronic Adjudication: Efficient. Secure. Reliable.
    Maricopa County Elections Department (copy hosted by ABC15)2021-04Primary documentCounty handout on the 2020 elections, created April 2021.
  7. 7
    The other Arizona election audit
    ABC15 Arizona2021-06-16Journalism
  8. 8
    Maricopa County Posts Final Unofficial Results for 2026 General Election
    Maricopa County Elections Department2026-11-11Primary documentThe site blocks automated requests. We read it in a browser.
  9. 9
    Post sharing a message from an unnamed Maricopa County adjudicator
    Rachel Alexander (@Rach_IC) on X2026-11-06Primary documentWrites for Townhall and Arizona Insiders. About 179,000 views as of Nov. 9. The message is cut off in the post.
  10. 10
  11. 11
    A.R.S. § 16-621: Proceedings at the counting center
    Arizona LegislaturePrimary document
  12. 12
    2025 Elections Procedures Manual (pp. 232, 234 and 269)
    Arizona Secretary of State (Internet Archive copy)2025-12-22Primary documentThe state's server blocks automated downloads. The archived copy is the same file.
  13. 13
  14. 14
    Maricopa County Posts Updated Unofficial Results for 2026 General Election: Saturday
    Maricopa County Elections Department2026-11-07Primary documentThe site blocks automated requests. We read it in a browser.
  15. 15
    Arizona 2026 General Election: unofficial results
    Arizona Secretary of State2026-11-11DataUnofficial, last updated Nov. 11, 2026, 8:02:58 p.m., all 15 counties reporting. Live page linked from azsos.gov. We read it in a browser.
  16. 16
    2026 November General Election Results by precinct (ArizonaExportByPrecinct_1111_516PM.txt)
    Maricopa County Elections Department2026-11-11DataFinal unofficial. Linked from the county's Election Results page, which replaced the Nov. 7 file at the same address. Our totals across 957 precincts.
  17. 17
  18. 18
    A.R.S. § 16-642: Canvass of election; postponements
    Arizona LegislaturePrimary document
  19. 19
    AUDIT USA v. Maricopa County, No. 1 CA-CV 22-0254
    Arizona Court of Appeals (via FindLaw)2023-02-14Primary document
  20. 20
  21. 21
    Bipartisan support for bill to make all Arizona ballots public
    Arizona Mirror (via Missoula Current)2023-02-09Journalism
  22. 22
    HB 2560: images; voter lists; records; contest (final House bill summary, vetoed)
    Arizona House of Representatives2023-05-30Primary document
  23. 23
    Maricopa County 2022 General Election Ballot-on-Demand Printer Investigation
    Ruth V. McGregor for Maricopa County2023-04-10ResearchIndependent review by a retired Arizona chief justice, commissioned by the county.
  24. 24
    Voter Engagement High for Midterms
    Gallup2026-10-29DataPoll conducted Oct. 1–19, 2026.
  25. 25
    Hand counts of votes may cause errors, says new Rice U. study
    Rice University2012-02-02ResearchUniversity news release on a Rice and Clemson study.
  26. 26
  27. 27
    Local Election Officials Survey 2026
    Brennan Center for Justice2026-04-13Advocacy / think tankLeft-leaning law and policy institute at NYU. Survey of 834 local election officials, margin of error ±3%.
  28. 28
    Arizona 2026 General Election: unofficial results
    Arizona Secretary of State2026-11-07DataUnofficial, last updated Nov. 7, 2026, 7:27 p.m. Live page linked from azsos.gov. We read it in a browser.
  29. 29
    2026 November General Election Results by precinct (ArizonaExportByPrecinct_1107_1116AM.txt)
    Maricopa County Elections Department2026-11-07DataUnofficial. Linked from the county's Election Results page. Our totals across 957 precincts.

Think we got something wrong? Email editor@viewfromthegallery.com with a source. Corrections are made openly and logged on the page.