Economy · Labor

Warren's child care numbers check out. 'Bottom third' undersells it

The typical child care worker earns $34,980 a year, in the bottom quarter of U.S. wage earners. The fight is over raising it.

· @SenWarren · on XThe post we're checking
The typical pay for child care workers is $34,000 a year.

That puts them in the bottom third of workers in the U.S. These are the people taking care of our babies.

In the richest country in the world, we can do better.
Screenshot of the post on X. Shown for commentary.
Read the post as text
The typical pay for child care workers is $34,000 a year. That puts them in the bottom third of workers in the U.S. These are the people taking care of our babies. In the richest country in the world, we can do better.

The bottom line

Warren's numbers hold up. BLS puts the typical child care worker at $34,980 a year, which assumes full-time hours many don't work. That's the bottom quarter of U.S. wage and salary workers, so "bottom third" undersells it1,2. The real fight is how to raise it: public money, or looser rules that cut what care costs to provide.

The claims

What the post says or clearly implies, checked one by one. How verdicts work

1

The typical pay for child care workers is $34,000 a year.

Checks out

BLS puts the median at $34,980 for May 2025, its newest data, and Warren rounded down. The yearly figure assumes full-time, year-round work, which many in the field don't get, so it flatters actual take-home pay.

Warren's post gives no source3. "Typical" here means the median: half earn more, half less. BLS puts the median for childcare workers at $16.82 an hour, or $34,980 a year, in May 20251. BLS's wage survey lists May 2025 as its newest year4.

BLS's yearly figures assume a full-time, year-round schedule of 2,080 hours5. BLS says part-time work is common in the job1, so many child care workers take home less than $34,980 in a year. The survey behind that median covers wage and salary workers in nonfarm establishments, not the self-employed or household workers4. It counts 518,910 childcare workers6.

UC Berkeley's Center for the Study of Child Care Employment, a research center that backs higher pay, measures "early educators": everyone who works with children from birth to age five, in centers or homes. Using a new methodology that includes self-employed providers, it found a 2022 median of $13.07 an hour7. That isn't directly comparable to BLS's $16.82.

2

That puts them in the bottom third of workers in the U.S.

Checks out

If anything, it understates. In the same BLS survey, a quarter of U.S. wage and salary workers earned less than $37,590 in May 2025. The typical child care worker, at $34,980, falls below that line, in the bottom quarter.

In May 2025, a quarter of U.S. wage and salary workers earned less than $37,590 a year2. The child care median, $34,980, sits below that1. Both yearly figures assume 2,080 hours5, so the comparison is like for like. A child care worker at the field's 75th percentile earned $38,570, barely above the line8.

Berkeley's center, using its own methodology that includes the self-employed, says 97 percent of other occupations are paid more than early educators7. That ranks jobs, not workers, but it points the same way.

The gap hasn't widened. A different BLS survey tracks hourly pay for nonsupervisory staff in child care businesses, an average across all their jobs ($19.69 in 2025), so it runs above the $16.82 occupation median. Before inflation, it rose 81% from 2007 to 2025 by our calculation, matching the private sector's 80%9,10. After inflation, child care pay rose about 16%, by our calculation9,11.

Child care pay kept pace with private pay. The gap stayed put

$0$5$10$15$20$25$30$352007200920112013201520172019202120232025

BLS series CEU6562440008, annual average, as published.

Average hourly earnings of nonsupervisory workers, annual averages, before inflation. Child care is the child care services industry, a mean across its jobs, so it runs above BLS's occupation median9. All private covers every private industry10. Child care stayed about 63% of the private average, by our calculation.
Show the numbers
Child care pay kept pace with private pay. The gap stayed put: the numbers
YearChild care industryAll private industries
2007$10.90$17.41
2008$11.32$18.06
2009$11.91$18.61
2010$11.99$19.04
2011$11.82$19.44
2012$11.83$19.73
2013$12.00$20.13
2014$12.44$20.60
2015$12.57$21.03
2016$12.77$21.53
2017$13.08$22.05
2018$13.50$22.71
2019$14.16$23.51
2020$14.97$24.68
2021$15.85$25.90
2022$17.50$27.57
2023$18.38$28.93
2024$19.12$30.13
2025$19.69$31.35

The real disagreement

Facts can't settle this part, so we don't rule on it.

Should taxpayers pay to raise child care wages, or should states loosen the rules that make care costly to provide?

Both sides start from the same squeeze. Child Care Aware of America, an advocacy and research group, puts the national average annual price of child care at $13,184 in 2025, averaged across 47 states. It found prices rose 23% from 2021 to 2025, against 24% for prices overall12. Over the longer run, since 2007, day care and preschool prices rose 80%, in step with child care pay and well ahead of overall prices (55%), by our calculation from BLS data13,11,9.

Public money should lift child care pay

Parents can't pay more, so low wages fill the gap. Public funding should pay care workers like the educators they are.

Low pay is already a hidden subsidy. Berkeley's center finds 13.1 percent of early educators earn below the poverty line, against 2.3 percent of elementary and middle school teachers. It says 43 percent of their families rely on programs like Medicaid and food stamps, costing taxpayers more than $4.7 billion a year7. The typical child care worker sits in the bottom quarter of U.S. wage earners2,1.

Supporters say public money works where it's spent. Teaching staff with a bachelor's degree in school-sponsored pre-K were paid more than $20,000 more a year than those in centers without public funding, a gap associated with public money7. Warren's Child Care for Every Community Act, reintroduced Sept. 30, 2025, would cap costs at 7% of income for higher-income families, fully cover families below 75% of state median income, and require wages and benefits comparable to similarly credentialed public school teachers14.

Ease the rules that make care costly

Rules on ratios and credentials drive up costs, and strict ratios hold down wages. Subsidies just move the bill to taxpayers.

Regulation makes care expensive. Economists Diana Thomas and Devon Gorry, for the free-market Mercatus Center in 2015, found that allowing one more infant per staff member is associated with 9 to 20 percent lower costs. Requiring lead teachers to hold a high school diploma was tied to 25 to 46 percent higher infant care costs15. Strict ratios also hold down wages, because more staff are needed for the same number of children15.

Ryan Bourne of the libertarian Cato Institute argued in 2018 that none of the proposed fixes for costly care would make it cheaper: "They would simply transfer the high costs to taxpayers." He cites research finding that tightening ratios by one child cuts the number of centers in an average area by 10 percent, with "no apparent impact on quality," and that the harm falls "almost entirely in poorer areas" and on single mothers16.

Where they agree

  • Neither side here disputes that care costs families a lot while the people providing it earn little12,1.
  • Mercatus calls caregiver training the key to quality, and Warren's bill funds worker training and professional development15,14.

What would change minds

  • Studies of states that loosened ratios, tracking whether prices fell, wages rose and child outcomes held.
  • Evidence on whether funded raises last, such as Utah's pandemic-era program tying grants to a $15 wage for at least half of staff, which ended when the money ran out7.

Sources

Every source was opened and read. Advocacy groups are labeled as such.

Show all 16 sources
  1. 1
    Childcare Workers, Occupational Outlook Handbook
    U.S. Bureau of Labor StatisticsMay 2025 wage dataData
  2. 2
  3. 3
    The typical pay for child care workers is $34,000 a year.
    Elizabeth Warren on X2026-11-16Primary document
  4. 4
    Occupational Employment and Wage Statistics: Overview
    U.S. Bureau of Labor StatisticsMay 15, 2026Data
  5. 5
  6. 6
  7. 7
    Early Childhood Workforce Index 2024: Key Findings
    Center for the Study of Child Care Employment, UC Berkeley2024ResearchUniversity research center that advocates for better pay for early educators
  8. 8
  9. 9
  10. 10
  11. 11
    Consumer Price Index: All items, U.S. city average (CUUR0000SA0)
    U.S. Bureau of Labor StatisticsDataAnnual averages, used to adjust for inflation
  12. 12
    Child Care in America: 2025 Price & Supply
    Child Care Aware of America2026Advocacy / think tankChild care resource and advocacy group
  13. 13
  14. 14
    Warren, Sherrill, 40+ Lawmakers Renew Push to Lower Child Care Costs
    Office of Sen. Elizabeth Warren2025-09-30Primary document
  15. 15
    Regulation and the Cost of Child Care
    Mercatus Center at George Mason University2015-08-17ResearchFree-market research center; working paper by Diana Thomas and Devon Gorry
  16. 16
    Want to Make Child Care Cheaper and More Accessible? Deregulate It.
    Cato Institute2018-08-14Advocacy / think tankLibertarian think tank; commentary by Ryan Bourne

Think we got something wrong? Email editor@viewfromthegallery.com with a source. Corrections are made openly and logged on the page.