Economy · Trade

Real refunds, some spent on bonuses. Shoppers have no direct claim.

Both companies tie bonus spending to their refunds. TJX accrued a third of its refund for bonuses, and shoppers have no direct refund route.

· @propublica · on XThe post we're checking
New: Stanley Black & Decker is getting at least $298 million in tariff refunds. The parent firm of TJ Maxx received $331 million. Both companies, and others, are using the money for corporate bonuses instead of repaying shoppers. https://propub.li/4kUXmvr
Screenshot of the post on X, with its link preview. Shown for commentary.
Read the post as text
New: Stanley Black & Decker is getting at least $298 million in tariff refunds. The parent firm of TJ Maxx received $331 million. Both companies, and others, are using the money for corporate bonuses instead of repaying shoppers. https://propub.li/4kUXmvr

The bottom line

Both refund figures match the companies' reports, and both tie bonus spending to the refunds. TJX accrued $112 million of its $331 million for bonuses. Stanley's related costs total at least $131.6 million, and its bonus share is undisclosed. Neither has said it will repay shoppers, and no federal law requires it. Whether they should is the real argument.

The claims

What the post says or clearly implies, checked one by one. How verdicts work

1

Stanley Black & Decker is getting at least $298 million in tariff refunds, and TJ Maxx's parent received $331 million.

Checks out

Stanley recognized pretax refund gains of $118 million and $180.7 million in its last two quarters, about $298.7 million through Q3 by our calculation. TJX received $331 million in refunds in its quarter ended Aug. 1.

The refunds exist because the Supreme Court ruled on Feb. 20 that the emergency-powers law President Trump used doesn't authorize tariffs1. Customs launched a refund system in April2. By Sept. 30 the government had paid about $130 billion of $166 billion in eligible refunds, by the count of the American Action Forum, a center-right group3. Our earlier piece covers what that did to the deficit4.

Stanley recorded a $118 million pretax gain from refunds in the second quarter and $180.7 million in the third, according to Manufacturing Dive and CFO Dive's reading of its filings5,6. Those are gains recognized, not a cash tally. CEO Chris Nelson said the company has "now received the vast majority of what we have applied for"7.

TJX said it received $331 million for "a portion of" the tariffs it paid8. It put the total it paid at about $490 million2. It expected more refunds in its third quarter8.

2

Both companies, and others, are using the tariff refund money for corporate bonuses.

Missing context

Both companies tie bonus spending to the refunds in their own reports. But TJX accrued $112 million of its $331 million for bonuses, for employees globally. Stanley hasn't said how much of its related costs went to bonuses.

TJX was explicit: "Due to these tariff refunds, the Company accrued incremental expenses of $112 million for year-end incentive compensation and discretionary bonuses for eligible Associates globally"8. That is about 34% of the refund, by our calculation, and it is an accrual, not yet paid. TJX hasn't said how far down the ranks the bonuses go, and said the rest "will be used to support our future growth"9.

Stanley says its refund gains were partially offset by "directly attributable variable incentive compensation costs, growth investments, and taxes (for EPS only)"10,11. Those pretax costs were $83.4 million and $48.2 million in the last two quarters, at least $131.6 million through Q3 by our calculation, with no split between bonuses and investments6. More offsets land in the fourth quarter, its finance chief said7. He cited $70 million to $80 million of growth spending pulled forward from 20276.

"And others" holds up. ProPublica counted at least nine companies using refunds for bonuses. One is Titleist's parent Acushnet, which disclosed about $12.0 million in incentive compensation expense9.

3

The companies are keeping the refunds instead of repaying the shoppers who paid tariff-inflated prices.

Checks out

Neither company has said it will repay shoppers, and TJX declined to say whether it would. Federal law gives the refund only to the importer of record. Whether shoppers are owed any of it is in dispute.

Only the "importer of record," the company that filed the entry with Customs, or its authorized customs broker can claim the refund12. Stanley raised prices citing the tariffs, and in November its CEO said list prices "are where we put them as we raised price as a result of the tariffs"9,7. Tools & Outdoor pricing was down 3% year over year in Q3, after flat pricing in Q2, which he tied to a promotional reset begun in Q4 and Q111,10,7.

Burlington said it would use its $55 million refund "to deliver sharper values for our customers"2. A shopper has sued Stanley, saying it "stands to recover the same tariff payments twice"13. Many such suits are "likely to face substantial threshold challenges on standing and ripeness grounds," a corporate law firm wrote in March14.

New York Fed economists found about 26% of the 2025 tariff increase passed through to consumer prices over 12 months, relative to less-exposed goods15. Harvard Business School's tracker put consumers' share at up to 43% over seven months16.

The real disagreement

Facts can't settle this part, so we don't rule on it.

When an importer gets back a tariff its customers helped pay, who should the money go to?

The law sends refunds to the importer of record12. Two studies found some of the cost reached shoppers, and they differ on how much15,16.

The money should reach the people who paid

Shoppers paid tariff-inflated prices, so a refund spent on bonuses is a windfall.

Companies told investors they were passing tariffs on. Stanley's executives described price increases tied to tariffs on several earnings calls9, and its list prices are still at those levels7. The Tax Foundation estimated the Trump tariffs raised taxes by an average of $1,000 per household in 202517. Three senators called a refund that skips consumers "a giveaway to giant corporations that amounts to theft from the middle class"18.

To this side, bonuses spent from a refund reward a windfall nobody at the company earned. "It was a government mistake that resulted in a refund," a Syracuse law professor told ProPublica9. Burlington pledged its refund to "sharper values" for customers, which ProPublica reads as lowering prices2,9. One lawsuit argues Stanley collected the tariff from shoppers and now collects it again from Washington13.

The refund belongs to whoever paid the duty

Importers paid the tariff and absorbed much of it, and bonuses reach workers too.

Importers wrote the checks, and the law repays them12. New York Fed economists found about 26% of the 2025 tariff increase reached consumer prices over 12 months15. Harvard's tracker put consumers' share at up to 43% over seven months, the rest borne by U.S. companies16. Treasury Secretary Bessent: "the American people had the money in the U.S. Treasury and we were forced to give it back"9.

Bonuses reach beyond the corner office. TJX's go to "eligible Associates globally"8. Williams-Sonoma allocated $10 million to one-time 401(k) payments, to reward employees19. A Cornell professor said it "could go both ways," but noted that if leaders "were penalized for something out of their control," rewarding them now "seems reasonable"9. Contract-based claims "may be vulnerable" because a retail sale is a contract at a set price and the tariffs were lawful when collected, defense lawyers wrote14.

Where they agree

  • Where a seller itemized a tariff surcharge on the bill, refunds are flowing back, as UPS and FedEx are doing for shipping customers9.
  • Both sides lack the full picture: the administration has declined to disclose which companies got refunds9.

What would change minds

  • A breakdown from TJX and Stanley of how much refund-linked bonus money went to executives versus hourly and store staff.
  • Product-level price data showing whether tariff-era prices at these companies fell after the refunds arrived.
  • Court rulings in the consumer class actions on whether shoppers have any legal claim to refunds.

Sources

Every source was opened and read. Advocacy groups are labeled as such.

Show all 19 sources
  1. 1
    Supreme Court Rules Against Tariffs Imposed Under the International Emergency Economic Powers Act (IEEPA)
    Congressional Research Service (EveryCRSReport copy)Feb. 23, 2026Research
  2. 2
  3. 3
    U.S. Treasury: FY 2026 Deficit Totaled $2 Trillion
    American Action ForumOct. 2026Advocacy / think tankCenter-right policy institute.
  4. 4
    Our breakdown of the record October deficit
    View from the GalleryJournalismCovers how tariff refunds cut customs receipts.
  5. 5
  6. 6
    Stanley Black & Decker raises EPS outlook after tariff refund boost
    CFO DiveNov. 4, 2026JournalismReports the 10-Q's $180.7 million gain and $48.2 million in offsetting costs, and the second quarter's $83.4 million.
  7. 7
    Stanley Black & Decker Q3 2026 Earnings Call, corrected transcript
    Stanley Black & Decker investor relations (FactSet CallStreet)Nov. 4, 2026Primary document
  8. 8
    TJX Reports Q2 FY27 Results; Above-Plan Comp Sales Growth of 4%
    The TJX Companies via Business Wire (Finviz copy)Aug. 2026Primary document
  9. 9
    Corporations Are Using Trump’s Tariff Refunds on Bonuses Rather Than Reimbursing Consumers
    ProPublicaNov. 16, 2026JournalismThe article the post links to.
  10. 10
    Stanley Black & Decker Reports Solid 2Q 2026 Results
    Stanley Black & DeckerJuly 29, 2026Primary document
  11. 11
    Stanley Black & Decker Reports 3Q 2026 Results
    Stanley Black & Decker via PR Newswire (Finviz copy)Nov. 4, 2026Primary document
  12. 12
    Who Gets Refunds? Litigation Trends After the Fall of IEEPA Tariffs
    DC Bar, Washington Lawyer2026JournalismBar association magazine.
  13. 13
    Stanley Black & Decker hit with class action over alleged tariff pricing scheme
    Top Class ActionsJuly 24, 2026JournalismSummarizes Rothschild v. Stanley Black & Decker, D. Conn. Allegations only.
  14. 14
    Consumer Class Actions Arising from IEEPA Tariff Refund Efforts
    Covington & BurlingMarch 2026Advocacy / think tankLaw firm that advises companies; client alert.
  15. 15
    The Anatomy of Tariff Pass-Through into Consumer Prices (Staff Report No. 1201)
    Federal Reserve Bank of New YorkAug. 2026, revised Sept. 2026Research
  16. 16
    Tariffs Leave Consumers and Companies Splitting the Tab
    Harvard Business School Working KnowledgeApril 27, 2026Research
  17. 17
    Trump Tariffs Tracker: Rates, Revenue, and Impact
    Tax FoundationUpdated Sept. 10, 2026Advocacy / think tankTax policy think tank.
  18. 18
    Welch, Warren, Booker Slam Trump on Illegal Tariff "Theft from the Middle Class"
    Office of Sen. Peter WelchFeb. 24, 2026Advocacy / think tankPress release from three Democratic senators.
  19. 19

Think we got something wrong? Email editor@viewfromthegallery.com with a source. Corrections are made openly and logged on the page.